Primary care specialist Methven Forbes of Forbes Healthcare examines the issues
The global healthcare system is facing a quiet but profound contradiction. We invest extraordinary sums in treating disease, yet comparatively little in keeping people well. Nowhere is this tension more visible than in the debate around out-of-hospital care, a theme explored in depth at the recent Healthcare World Forum in Dubai.
While Dubai’s healthcare system differs markedly from those in the UK and other mature markets, the challenges it faces are strikingly familiar — and instructive. One of the most consistent themes to emerge from the Dubai discussion was that the traditional language of healthcare is no longer serving us. The distinctions between primary, secondary and tertiary care are becoming increasingly artificial. Care is now delivered across a continuum spanning clinics, hospitals, homes, community settings and digital platforms.
The setting is no longer the defining feature. What matters instead is outcomes, continuity and coordination. Patients are also more informed than ever before, with online access to an enormous repository of preventative and curative healthcare information, although that information is not always accurate. Specialists and clinical teams now operate within a landscape shaped by a population that is increasingly health-literate, informed and proactive.
Consequently, many patients view primary care less as the setting responsible for directing and coordinating their care, and more as a procedural hurdle they must overcome to access specialists and diagnostic services they have already decided they require. This is particularly evident in mature healthcare systems with a long-established primary care model. In the UK, for example, general practice has historically acted as the anchor of the healthcare system, coordinating care across multiple specialties.
However, sustained pressure on GP services, workforce shortages, rising demand and increased patient mobility have gradually eroded that coordinating role. In Dubai, patients often enjoy rapid and direct access to specialists, but may lack a single point of accountability for their overall care. In both contexts, the result is fragmentation. This fragmentation creates frustration among an increasingly health-literate population that often believes it already understands what care is required.
Activity, Not Outcomes
The traditional distinctions within healthcare are also under pressure from the way healthcare markets and payment systems are designed. Dubai’s healthcare market illustrates clearly how incentives can shape behaviour. With largely volume-based reimbursement and consumer-driven choice, providers are rewarded for activity rather than outcomes. Patients with comprehensive insurance understandably seek specialist opinions, even when these may not be clinically necessary. Clinicians, acting responsibly within their professional frameworks, may then feel obliged to investigate extensively in order to rule out serious pathology.
The cumulative effect is over-utilisation, rising costs and care that is not always proportionate to the patient’s needs. In the NHS, constrained access can delay diagnosis. In Dubai, unfettered access can encourage over-diagnosis. The former is often the result of limited capacity and cost containment, while the latter can arise from over-capacity and cost inflation. Both are symptoms of healthcare systems that struggle to define clear boundaries around the purpose of healthcare provision. What should governments and insurers fund?
What responsibility should reasonably sit with the individual when behaviour or inaction contributes to ill health? Fundamentally, this raises the question of where the boundary lies between curative and preventative medicine on the one hand, and the wider social determinants of health on the other. Layered onto this challenge is the persistent difficulty of aligning incentives with health outcomes rather than healthcare activity.
Changing the Model
One of the most important insights from Dubai was the recognition that out-of-hospital care cannot simply mean care that is delivered somewhere other than a hospital. It must represent a fundamentally different model focused on prevention, early intervention, chronic disease management and behavioural change. This requires a workforce configured very differently from the one operating today. It also requires a clear understanding of what is meant by prevention and behavioural change.
For example, should healthcare systems fund access to clean water and roads leading to clinics in areas where either is limited? To what extent should healthcare systems incentivise healthier choices or penalise behaviours that contribute to poor health? The difficulty is that when the healthcare landscape is divided into its main components, and then divided further into specialties and sub-specialties, clinicians are rarely trained or supported to deliver lifestyle medicine at scale. This is evident in both Dubai and the UK.
Lifestyle medicine encompasses nutrition, physical activity, sleep, social and community wellbeing, purpose, financial security and mental wellbeing. There is broad acknowledgement that these factors are central to health outcomes, yet they remain poorly embedded in everyday clinical practice. Alternatively, responsibility for them is devolved to primary care without the training, resources or wider system support required to deliver them effectively.
In response, healthcare systems often fragment further by placing additional allied health professionals alongside primary and secondary care teams. However, these roles are frequently not regarded as part of the core clinical team and are not fully integrated into defined care pathways. The result is under-utilisation, regulatory constraint and professional marginalisation, rather than the coherent, multidisciplinary approach required to improve population health outcomes.
Data and Integration
Dubai’s experience also highlights the central role of data in enabling integration. Without shared records, interoperable systems and clear governance, the burden of coordinating care falls on informal communication between providers, referral letters and patients themselves. Expecting individuals to navigate complex healthcare systems, reconcile conflicting advice and manage long-term conditions without structured support is unrealistic.
While patients are becoming more health-literate, that does not necessarily mean they understand how their local healthcare economy operates. Abu Dhabi’s more assertive public health approach, including mandatory screening, integrated digital platforms and population-level oversight, demonstrates what decisive government action can deliver within complex healthcare markets. Although this approach may not translate directly to every healthcare system, the underlying principle is universal: health systems should be designed around population health rather than organisational convenience.
Rethinking Regulation
The same principle applies to healthcare regulation. In the UK, the Care Quality Commission regulates premises, systems and clinical professionals. Yet it has been widely described as not being fit for purpose. This is perhaps unsurprising given that the CQC is expected to span health and safety, employment law, leadership theory, business practice, public health, health economics, professional regulation and clinical practice simultaneously. By contrast, healthcare systems in the Middle East often recognise a clearer separation between premises licensing and professional regulatory oversight. For the UK and other mature healthcare systems, the lesson is clear. Out-of-hospital care cannot remain an afterthought or be treated primarily as a cost-containment exercise. It must become a core operating model for healthcare.
This requires a shift from volume-based reimbursement towards value- and quality-based models, in which providers are rewarded for regulatory compliance, clinical quality and adherence to defined care pathways. Beyond this, systems must reward the maintenance of health, rather than simply the treatment of illness. However, this ambition cannot be pursued without acknowledging the limits of healthcare’s influence. If healthcare systems are to remain affordable, accountability for outcomes must be shared realistically between providers, payers and individuals.
Defining the Social Contract
Ultimately, the debate in Dubai may have reinforced a simple but uncomfortable truth. We have yet to define, or agree, what a government- or insurer-funded healthcare system should reasonably include and exclude. We have also yet to establish a clear social contract with patients on that basis. Without this clarity, healthcare systems will continue to struggle, creaking under the weight of fragmentation as they attempt to respond to each new challenge in isolation.
Have some thoughts on the topic? Share them with the community here